SKY Journal of Linguistics, vol. 16:2003
Abstracts
Agurtzane Elordui: Variation in the Grammar of Endangered Languages: The Case of Two
Basque Dialects
Researches addressing variation in language loss suggest that the factors
underlining variation in endangered languages differ from the factors
that account for variation in healthy languages. The results of this study
focused on the patterns of variation across the language use of different
speakers of two dying dialects of Basque, also show that differences related
with the social status of the speakers do not explain the morpho-syntactic
variation found in these dialects. The data indicate that the patterns
of variation found in these terminal communities can be better accounted
for in terms of differentiation in the degree of language use frequency
of the speakers and in the diversity of their acquisitional backgrounds.
These results come to confirm King's proposal according to which variation
arises in dying languages as a result of a language death process whereby
simplified variants gradually replace more complex variants, especially
in the speech of semi-speakers (King 1989: 139). Likewise, the analysis
of the overgeneralized or new variants used particularly by semi-speakers
reveals that linguistic considerations such as scale of morphological
complexity of the variant, markedness and semantic and morphological transparency
have a relevant importance in order to explain the linguistic nature of
this variation.
Remus Gergel: Modal Syntax: Detecting its Parameters with VP-Ellipsis
Recent syntactic approaches unconventionally transfer semantic modal
distinctions to syntactic structure or syntax-relevant observations with
the evidence usually concentrating on scope (relative to negation, quantifiers,
etc). This paper discusses why such interesting preliminary indications
are less than fully satisfactory. Moreover, it argues for at least a local
co-encoding of modal parameters in English syntax with corroborating support
based on licensing of VP-ellipsis. Evidence is presented in which dichotomies
between (i) differently grammaticalized modals, (ii) epistemic/deontic
modals, and (iii) universal/existential modal force, respectively, interfere
with ellipsis in diagnostically telling ways.
Tapio Hokkanen: Interruption and Timing in Self initiated Repairs
Despite certain limitations in observational approaches, self-initiated
repairs following naturally occurring slips of the tongue are believed
to reveal representations and processes related to speech monitoring.
In the present study, self-repairs are analyzed from two points of view:
from the placement of interruption and continuation points on the one
hand, and from the timing of repairs on the other. It appears, firstly,
that speakers tend to complete the troublesome words before interrupting
their speech flow and, secondly, that also the continuations predominantly
respect lexical integrity. Both findings presumably contribute to the
listener's chance to reconstruct the interrupted message. As regards to
the timing factors, most cut-offs are placed either within the troublesome
word or after the first word boundary after it. The role of repairs on
the fly is also discussed. Finally, it is concluded that the speaker has
the final choice of either repairing the error or ignoring it as well
as of making the repair well-formed or not.
Richard Ingham: The Changing Status of Middle English OV Order: Evidence from Two
Genres
Various accounts of OV order in Middle English have been proposed, in
particular the approach of Kroch & Taylor (2000) in which quantified
(including negated) and ordinary objects receive different analyses, on
the assumption of a constant rate of leftward scrambling of quantified
objects. The present study revisits Middle English OV, eliminating heavy
NPs which may bias outcomes towards VO. 13th century and 15th century
prose and verse data are analysed for OV or VO order. It is shown that
on this basis the frequency of OV with all types of object (negated, other
quantified, and ordinary) is almost identical in EME. However, negated
objects dissociate markedly from other types in later Middle English.
It is proposed that the assumption of a constant rate of leftward scrambling
of negated objects in Middle English be abandoned in favour of the NegP
reanalysis approach in van der Wurff (1999) and Ingham (2000, 2003), which
in turn may require a revision of the Kroch & Taylor model.
Leonid Kulikov: The Labile Syntactic Type in a Diachronic Perspective: The Case
of Vedic
(unfortunately the fonts of the examples cannot be displayed right in
the following abstract)
Ancient Indo-European verbal syntax, as attested in early Vedic Sanskrit,
exhibits numerous examples of the labile syntactic pattern: several verbal
forms can show valence alternation with no formal change in the verb;
cf. pres. svádate 'he makes sweet' / 'he is sweet'; perf.
vavrdhuh 'they have grown' (intr.) / 'they have increased' (tr.).
I will argue that the labile patterning of the Vedic verb, however common
it may appear, is mostly of a secondary character. There are a limited
number of reasons which give rise to labile syntax: (i) the polyfunctionality
of the middle inflection (which can be used to mark the anticausative,
passive and reflexive functions, on the one hand, and the self-beneficent
meaning of the transitive forms, on the other); (ii) the homonymy of some
middle participles 'shared' by passive (medio-passive aorist, stative)
and non-passive formations; (iii) the syntactic reanalysis of intransitive
constructions with the accusative of parameter/scope (content accusative)
as transitive-causative. As to the perfect, it could probably be employed
both intransitively and transitively already in Proto-Indo-European, although
the intransitive usages were prevalent. In the historical period the newly-built
perfect middle forms have largely taken over the intransitive function,
but active perfects are still quite common in the (more archaic) intransitive
usages in early Vedic.
The analysis of the development of lability in Vedic uncovers general
mechanisms of the rise and decay of the labile syntactic type and thus
furnish important evidence for its typological study.
Pirita Pyykkönen, Jussi Niemi & Juhani
Järvikivi Sentence Structure, Temporal Order and Linearity: Slow Emergence of
Adult-like Syntactic Performance in Finnish
The present study investigated the comprehension of Finnish temporal structures
by eight, ten, and twelve-year-old native Finnish school children. More
precisely, a written questionnaire off-line experiment investigated the
comprehension of subordinating clause structures with conjunctions ennen
kuin 'before' and sen jälkeen kun 'after' as well as the comprehension
of sentences with both referative and temporal converb constructions. The
experiment showed that the performance of the eight-year-old group was significantly
more error prone than the performance of the two older age groups in all
structures investigated. They also showed a slow emergence of adult-like
performance by the age of twelve in all sentences. Moreover, the results
indicated that the youngest group relied on linearity significantly more
than the other two groups in their interpretation of the experimental sentences.
For the other two groups, the results showed that they relied significantly
more on the grammatical interpretation of the sentences.
Jae Jung Song: Resumptive Genitive Pronouns in Korean Relative Clauses:Distribution
and Explanation
This paper provides an explanatory account of the distribution of resumptive
genitive pronouns in Korean relative clauses. The use of resumptive genitive
pronouns depends crucially on the bondedness of the NOM-marked NP and
the predicate inside the relative clause. When these two expressions exhibit
syntactic and semantic bondedness, the use of resumptive genitive pronouns
is prohibited. If they are neither syntactically nor semantically bonded
to each other, a resumptive genitive pronoun must be utilized. If they
are syntactically, not semantically, bonded to each other, there is a
choice between the use and non-use of resumptive genitive pronouns. Moreover,
the notion of syntactic and semantic bondedness is compared with Kumashiro's
(2000) notion of partially or highly autonomous layered interrelation
with the conclusion that the latter must be redefined or reconceptualized
in terms of the two different kinds of bondedness, syntactic and semantic.
The paper closes with a brief discussion of general implications of these
findings.
Søren Wichmann: The Grammaticalization and Reanalysis of a Paradigm of Auxiliaries
in Texistepec Popoluca: A Case Study in Diachronic Adaptation
A series of morphosyntactic changes relating to aspect-mode auxiliaries
in the Texistepec Popoluca language will be analyzed under the hypothesis
that the changes in question are motivated by three factors: phonological
changes triggering new paradigmatic arrangements, areal convergence, and
the tendency for creating structures that are in conformity with a certain
over-all language type. As part of the overall diachronic account it is
explained how a segment k came to form part of the paradigm of person
markers even though this segment originally belonged to a preverbal adverbial
particle and had nothing to do with person marking. The diachronic data
bring support to the theoretical notion of 'diachronic adaptation' proposed
by Haspelmath (1999).
Jussi Ylikoski: Defining Non-finites: Action Nominals, Converbs and Infinitives
In the recent typological literature on non-finite verb forms-converbs,
infinitives, action nominals and participles-these forms have been defined
both in terms of (i) their word-classes and (ii) their syntactic functions,
often without differentiating between the two points of view. On the basis
of data from Uralic and Indo-European languages of Europe, this paper
is intended to clarify and refine the definitions of action nominals,
converbs and infinitives. It appears that action nominals can be defined
quite simply as verbal nouns (and participles as verbal adjectives), whereas
infinitives and converbs are better defined with reference to their complementary
functions, the difference between the two categories lying in their relative
obligatoriness vs. optionality in a sentence. Furthermore, it is argued
that the mutual relations of various non-finites are best understood by
examining them from both synchronic and diachronic perspectives simultaneously,
as converbs and infinitives often have their origins in case-marked action
nominals.